Originally released on Dorian, these fine performances constitute the only complete cycle currently available of the 17 string quartets that pepper Villa-Lobos’ entire career. The suite-like, five-movement No. 1, with its adorable “like a jumping bean” finale, is deceptive. Most of these are resoundingly neo-classical works full of acerbic harmonies and typically busy counterpoint, with few overtly nationalistic elements. Of course they sound just like Villa-Lobos, who was himself something of a “nationalistic element” when you come right down to it. The series reaches its culmination in the large works composed around the time of the Second World War, Nos. 7-11, which really do constitute landmark 20th century contributions to the form on a par with those of Shostakovich and Bartók.
For the most part, this is tough and serious music, and it receives tough and serious performances from the Cuarteto Latinoamericano, whose rhythmic verve and slightly astringent timbre works beautifully in clarifying the dense thicket of the composer’s effusive counterpoint. Occasionally the very intensity of both music and performance becomes a bit overbearing, but then no one is suggesting that you listen to 17 quartets in a row. Overall, both the works themselves and these performances remain astonishingly consistent in quality. Sonically you couldn’t ask for better. At budget price, this is a very attractive proposition for anyone who fancies either the composer or chamber music in general. [9/24/2004]
