Carnegie Hall, New York: October 10, 2002 Let's get right the point: there was a lot to enjoy in Michael Tilson Thomas' Mahler Third, and what problems there were stem from the strange fact that most conductors eventually become their...
The content you’re trying to view is for
Please register by clicking the button below in order to access this content.
(Already a member? Use the “Insider Login” button at the top of the site)
Over the past 15 years at ClassicsToday.com, we have earned a reputation for honest, hard-hitting, no-nonsense music criticism.
ClassicsToday Insider offers both beginners and serious collectors of classical recordings a new, enjoyable and informative way of accessing and reading reviews—an experience specifically adapted to the Internet. At only $49 for an entire year:
- All new Insider reviews include sound clips—often multiple–carefully selected to illustrate musical highlights, comparisons, and points of interest. Check out this sample
- Dozens of exclusive new reviews every month.
- Dedicated Insider review archive. Preview it now.
- Insider feature reviews include not just new releases, but also major catalog titles and reissue titles not covered anywhere else on the site.
- Dedicated search functions, including:
- Search by ratings
- Search by review type: Reference Recording, CD From Hell, Major Discoveries, Big Boxes, Under The Radar, Historical Gems, and other helpful categories that allow you to follow your interest and build your collection.
- Search Insider titles exclusively
- Lively editorial commentary.
- Weekly email notice of new reviews.
None of this material will be published on the main website. It is being offered by subscription only.
We pledge that CLASSICSTODAY INSIDER will give you more of what you’ve come to expect from us over the years, and by becoming a ClassicsToday Insider you will help maintain our editorial independence and allow us to continue to offer the most informative, knowledgeable, and entertaining body of music criticism available anywhere.
Latest ClassicsToday Insider Reviews:
by David Hurwitz
George Crumb returns to his favorite poet, Lorca, for the texts of Ghosts of Alhambra, even includin... Continue ReadingBig Boxes: John Ogdon’s Astonishing RCA Recordings
by David Hurwitz
The excellent booklet notes by our very own Jed Distler constitute a more perceptive review than thi... Continue ReadingHistorical Gems: Beinum’s Budget Bruckner
by David Hurwitz
Now available from Australian Eloquence, Beinum's Bruckner recordings are classics--as unique as the... Continue Reading
Search Music Reviews
Latest 10 / 10 Reviews
March 30, 2014 by David Hurwitz
This is an important recording for several reasons. First, it contains the finest version yet recorded of Glière's epic Third Symphony, "Il'ya Muromets". Second, it defines once and for all how the p... Continue ReadingOuvertures Pittoresques–State-Of-The-Art Telemann
March 21, 2014 by John Greene
Telemann drew inspiration from just about every national genre and style of the period throughout his lengthy and prolific career. Alluding to this diversity, this program titled "Ouvertures pittoresq... Continue ReadingIgor Levit’s Stunning Late-Beethoven Debut
March 11, 2014 by Jed Distler
All of the positive attention and high praise that 26-year-old pianist Igor Levit has garnered in Europe is thoroughly justified by his Sony Classical debut release encompassing Beethoven’s last fiv... Continue Reading
Latest Music Reviews
April 13, 2014 by David Hurwitz
Iván Fischer offers a strange commentary on the Fifth Symphony in the booklet accompanying this CD. He describes the work as Mahler's most "Jewish" symphony, proceeding from Jewish lamentation (no ar... Continue ReadingMax Reger’s (not so) Easy Pieces
April 13, 2014 by Jed Distler
Take these work titles with a grain of salt, for Reger’s Op. 67 Chorale Preludes and Op. 56 Preludes and Fugues are not all that easy to play. Yet their relatively modest scale might appeal to liste... Continue Reading50 Years Later: The Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center
April 11, 2014 by Jed Distler
How well I remember borrowing the Columbia-Princeton Electronic Music Center LP from the West Orange, New Jersey public library when I was nine years old, back in 1965, the year after its release. I p... Continue Reading