Bernstein’s Brahms always has been a source of some controversy, though this earlier symphony cycle is not as mannered and perverse (or just plain slow) as his later version with the Vienna Philharmonic on DG. In fact, there’s very little wrong with this fine performance of the First Symphony, and the performance of the Serenade No. 2 is a clear winner. Bernstein’s tempos throughout are judicious and the climaxes well-judged–in fact he doesn’t do anything especially strange. What the performance lacks is the last ounce of warmth in the orchestral playing, and perhaps a slightly more disciplined approach from the podium. In fact, if the competition in this music weren’t so strong, this performance no doubt would rate more highly. Unfortunately, the competition is murderous, and with great performances by Klemperer, Szell, Wand, and numerous others ready to hand, it’s hard to muster much enthusiasm for one that’s merely good. Bernstein fans will want this, and anyone else certainly won’t be disappointed. It’s just that you can do better.
