In his booklet note conductor David Montgomery makes the argument that Leonard Bernstein’s approach to his own music was not the only way, especially when that approach often varied. Fair enough, and as James Judd proved in his recording of Bernstein’s Symphony No. 1, and as Leonard Slatkin did with the Fancy Free Ballet, there are some conductors who can give Bernstein a run for his money. That Montgomery does not do so in this case is not due to any lack of conviction on his part, but rather to the Jena Philharmonic which, as earnestly as its members play, is simply not up to the level of the New York or Israel Philharmonics, both of which made fabulous recordings under the composer’s direction.
Now, if you can cleanse your mind of those performance memories, you won’t miss their jazzy brazenness and polished virtuosity as you listen to this CD, which ultimately is pretty decent. Candide goes at a good clip, West Side Story is quite touching in the love scenes and builds considerable energy in the dance sequences, and On the Waterfront displays the requisite drama and pathos. Fancy Free, despite Dennis Heath’s rather dull and un-bluesy rendition of Big Stuff Blues, offers much engaging color and rhythmic sparkle. So ultimately, this well-recorded disc is really for those new to this music who’d like to try it all in one package at a bargain price. Listeners wanting to experience Bernstein’s work with all the appropriate pizzaz should hear it from the man himself.
