BELLS FOR STOKOWSKI

Review by: ClassicsToday

Artistic Quality: 10

Sound Quality: 10

The disc title promises sonority, sonority, sonority. The 24-bit HDCD stereo recording begins with timpani, then more drums, then other percussion, then brass, all roaring and pounding out the start of a brilliant arrangement by Patrick Dunnigan of selections from Susato’s The Danserye. The sound is just as real as it can be, utterly without strain or congestion, the contrabassoons buzzing, the horns barking, the trombones and trumpets crackling. I’m a fan for SACD surround, but this sounds cleaner, more natural, and even more spatially defined than at least 85 percent of the discs I’ve heard in the newer format.

Jerry Junkin and the University of Texas Wind Ensemble are first rate throughout. Their alert, lively performances have the electricity of a Texas line storm, but also are notable for their precise tuning and excellent ensemble. In Ralph Vaughan Williams’ English Folk Song Suite they are in no way inferior to the classic Fennell recording on Telarc. Two premieres round out the disc. The title work is Michael Daugherty’s band transcription of a movement of his Philadelphia Stories symphony for orchestra. It is a stunner, inspired the the image of Leopold Stokowski making a sunrise visit to the Liberty Bell and hearing the bells of the city begin to peal. Along the way, Daugherty makes a musical tour of typical American orchestral music textures of the past century, often piling them up in simultaneous layers. Two percussionists at opposite sides of the stage keep bell sounds floating above it all. (The whole work in its original orchestral form is available on a Naxos CD.)

David del Tredici is less radical than Daugherty in the post-Romantic original wind work, which he named In Wartime because composition of this commission coincided with the four months of debate and build-up before the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Its two connected sections (“Hymn” and “Battlemarch”) are suggestive but not graphic in evoking war; waves of music built on motives from Tristan und Isolde are juxtaposed over an Iraqi national song, but this is not overt battle music. Finally, the music unexpectedly collapses into a wailing, descending siren sound, leaving devastation. There is no celebration of victory and no choosing of sides, but neither is this a piece that spits anger. It doesn’t rail against war. Instead, it just seems to say “War happens”. And that’s perhaps the most bitter way of looking at it. If you are any kind of fan of concert band music, you must get this disc. [1/11/2006]



Buy Now from Arkiv Music

Recording Details:

Album Title: BELLS FOR STOKOWSKI
Reference Recording: English Folk Song Suite: Fennell (Telarc)

Works for wind ensemble by Tielman Susato, Ralph Vaughan Williams, David del Tredici, & Michael Daugherty -


Share This Review: