RCA’s new Classic Library series hits a high mark with this excellent Debussy/Munch collection. Charles Munch’s Debussy performances always have been treasured for their color, vitality, and seeming oneness with the composer’s conception. It’s hard to imagine finer performances of Images or the two Nocturnes. Munch’s rhythmic sense and timbral distinctiveness vividly render Debussy’s multi-layered textures and subtly varied moods. Then there’s the Boston Symphony, captured at the height of its glory, offering vibrant, virtuoso playing from all sections. Listen to the burnished brass in the first movement of Iberia, the lively woodwinds in Fêtes, or the silken strings in Nuages. Munch’s suave La Mer is at a slightly lower level of intensity and must yield to Boulez’s brilliant Cleveland performance on DG.
RCA’s sound for the most part is so vivid and dynamic (La Mer carries a bit of tape hiss) that you hardly can believe the recordings are more than 40 years old. If only the missing Sirènes movement from Nocturnes had been included, this would serve as a Debussy orchestral-music library staple. As it stands it’s a great–and essential, if supplemental, collection. [5/19/2004]
