These are extremely fine recordings, topped only by Boulez himself on DG, performances not necessarily “better”, but certainly sonically superior. Still, I retain a marginal preference for this ebullient and harrowing La Valse, and the super-precise and super-cool Cleveland interpretation of the Rapsodie is unique. Whether those qualities are what you want in this particular piece is very much a matter of personal choice; in his Berlin remake, Boulez put a little more meat on the music’s bones. Boléro builds to a massively powerful climax, and both Alborada del Gracioso (in Cleveland again) and the Daphnis suite are just about as good as it gets in this music. The sound suits the different orchestras: chamber-like in Cleveland, big and even boomy in New York, with a touch of glassiness to the strings in louder passages. At less than full price, this is an extremely good deal, even if you already have tons of Ravel in your collection. [4/20/2006]
