Campion songs/Chance/North

Review by: David Vernier

Artistic Quality: 9

Sound Quality: 9

Taking their cue from poet/composer Thomas Campion’s own avowed devotion to simplicity in his music, the performers on this delightful song recital strive for clarity of vocal delivery, uncluttered accompaniments, and an overall intimacy that’s well-served by the warm yet amply resonant acoustic. Most of the 25 selections are for solo voice, but a few involve all three of the singers who together form the ensemble The English Ayre, a group organized by lutenist Nigel North and “devoted exclusively to English Song of the 17th century.” (How specialized we’ve become!) These first rate singers (along with North and “guest” Michael Chance) are joined by another specialty group, Concordia, which exists “to explore music involving viols of all shapes and sizes.” The various vocal and instrumental combinations work well together, especially those that feature North’s gently pointed, perfectly phrased lute accompaniments. Nevertheless, one of the disc’s highlights is the final track, where countertenor Michael Chance is joined by the viol consort for a very moving rendition of the classic “Never weather-beaten sail.”

The program includes many of Campion’s best-known songs, notably “Fire, fire”, “There is a garden in her face”, “The Cypress curtain of the night is spread”, and the abovementioned “Never weather-beaten sail”. But we also get such interestingly titled fare as “Break now my heart and die”, “Turn back you wanton flyer”, and “Beauty is but a painted hell”. All four singers are ideal for this music and each is given a chance to shine. Another recently issued disc of Campion songs on Hyperion (type Q4846 in Search Reviews), with countertenor Robin Blaze and lutenist Elizabeth Kenny (occasionally joined by theorbo and viols), features many of these same songs. It’s an equally compelling, expertly made recording that although slightly different in interpretive nuance makes an ideal companion to this program–and offers intriguing comparisons.

Buy Now from Arkiv Music

Recording Details:

Reference Recording: Blaze/Kenny (Hyperion)

THOMAS CAMPION - English Ayres

  • Michael Chance (countertenor)
    Rachel Elliott (soprano)
    Mark Padmore (tenor)
    Peter Harvey (baritone)
    Nigel North (lute)
  • Concordia

Share This Review: