Your guide to classical music online

Mahler: Another “Meh” Symphony No. 5

David Hurwitz

Artistic Quality:

Sound Quality:

The good news is that the sonics in both regular stereo and SACD multichannel playback are excellent. The bad news is that this performance, while adequate as a representation of the notes on the page, is far less than world-class and has nothing noteworthy to recommend it whatsoever. Norichika Iimori’s interpretation sounds cautious (the scherzo runs more than 18 minutes), comparatively uninflected in the opening funeral march, and literal to a fault. The playing of the Württembergische Philharmonie Reutlingen, although acceptable technically, lacks character (winds), body of tone (strings), and boldness (brass). Take for example the final devastating collapse at the end of the second movement: there isn’t one. You hardly notice that anything has happened, a point that could be made again and again as the performance proceeds. I take pride in my willingness to acclaim an underdog (think of that sensational Mahler Fifth on ABC Classics featuring the Melbourne Symphony under Markus Stenz), but this particular dog is just that.


Recording Details:

Reference Recording: Barshai (Brilliant Classics), Bernstein (DG)

GUSTAV MAHLER - Symphony No. 5

  • Record Label: EBS - 6144
  • Medium: SACD

Search Music Reviews

Search Sponsor

  • Insider Reviews only
  • Click here for Search Tips

Visit Our Merchandise Store

Visit Store
  • Ideally Cast Met Revival of Gounod’s Roméo et Juliette
    Metropolitan Opera House, Lincoln Center, NY; March 19, 2024—The Met has revived Bartlett Sher’s 1967 production of Gounod’s R&J hot on the heels of its
  • An Ozawa Story, November, 1969
    Much has justifiably been written regarding Seiji Ozawa’s extraordinary abilities and achievements as a conductor, and similarly about his generosity, graciousness, and sense of humor
  • Arvo Pärt’s Passio At St. John The Divine
    Cathedral of St John the Divine, New York, NY; January 26, 2024—When one thinks of musical settings of Christ’s Passion, one normally thinks of the