Volume 2 of Chandos’ enterprising Bridge edition makes a better overall impression than did Volume 1, though on the whole it has similar virtues and vices. First, let’s say categorically that it’s wonderful to have this music (especially the Dance Poem and Dance Rhapsody, which are both terrific pieces) readily available in what are basically very good performances. Richard Hickox elicits some beautiful playing from the orchestra (the opening chord of The Sea positively glows with inner light), but his casual approach to rhythm and accent robs the music of some of its vibrancy. For example, in The Sea he’s a minute slower than Groves’ classic EMI account in the first movement, though he whips up a satisfyingly stormy finale, and the BBC National Orchestra of Wales has greater polish (if perhaps less timbral character) than Groves’ Liverpool band. Also, both “dance” works benefit from plenty of natural momentum that keeps them buoyant, which is more than can be said for the early tone poems included in this series’ first release. Chandos’ sonics, which are lovely but soft-edged, add to the overall smooth impression; more prominent percussion would have injected a welcome touch of extra energy. But these are not serious faults, and the music is so attractive that on this basis alone many will find this disc to be self-recommending. [11/1/2002]
